|
Abstract
A definition of ADHD and its symptoms are given. Adults are now
being diagnosed with ADHD. Statistics of the rising number of
children and adults diagnosed with ADHD are given. Assessment
of the disorder, and the role of the doctors, teachers, and parents
is discussed. Ritalin is the drug of choice for those diagnosed
with ADHD. Harmful side effects of this drug are given and alternatives
to medication are also discussed. Drug abuse of Ritalin is now
being reported. Children are using Ritalin as a recreational drug
by snorting it like cocaine.
ADHD And The Ritalin Crisis
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is one of the
fastest growing illnesses in America today. It effects children
and adults alike. Methylphendiate Hydrochloride (Ritalin) is the
drug prescribed most for this condition. A thorough assessment
of the problem is critical in order to diagnose the problem and
avoid an improper dosage which can lead to overdosing. There are
many side effects to consider before taking this drug. Unfortunately,
Ritalin is being used by children today as a recreational drug
the same way that cocaine is used. There are alternatives besides
Ritalin to treat ADHD.
What Is Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder?
ADHD, also known as ADD, was first recognized in 1980 and is considered
to be a mental disorder. This qualifies the child for special
treatment under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Approximately
three million children in America are said to have ADHD. In 1985,
ten boys were diagnosed with ADHD to every one girl. Since then,
the gap has gotten smaller. In 1995, five boys were diagnosed
to every one girl.
The causes for ADHD are unknown. Some believe
that it comes from a genetic dysfunction, more likely a short
circuit in the brain. Others believe that it could be caused by
the pregnant mother's use of cigarettes, alcohol, and illicit
drugs. It could also be caused from factors in the environment
like lead, mercury, cadmium, insecticides, and herbicides, overprocessing
of food additives, sugar, and allergies to foods such as milk,
wheat, and corn. Research has found that identical twins are both
diagnosed with ADHD 51% of the time and fraternal twins 33% of
the time therefore, the problem could be genetic. There is no
strong evidence to support any of these claims.
Symptoms of ADHD are inattentiveness, impulsiveness,
hyperactivity, and talkativeness. Students seldom complete homework,
class assignments, exams, or projects in the time period required.
They are usually disorganized, forgetful, and have a hard time
following the rules. The symptoms are usually revealed by the
age of seven; however, a growing number of adults are being diagnosed
with the disorder as well.
What is Ritalin
Ritalin is used in 90% of all cases diagnosed with ADHD. Ritalin
is an amphetamine. It comes in a tablet form, in regular and sustained
released formulas. It is recommended that it be taken twice a
day, usually at breakfast and lunch. Ritalin is the drug of choice
for those diagnosed with ADHD. In 1993, children in America consumed
three times as much Ritalin as the children in the rest of the
world. Most of the children taking Ritalin are males. Ciba-Geigy
Corporation is the company that manufactures Ritalin. Each year
they produce 8.5 tons of Ritalin, of which 90% is consumed by
the United States. The average cost of Ritalin is about $9.45
per week.
Assessment
Psychiatrists have found it very difficult to
diagnose ADHD; the symptoms are close to mania and depression.
Proper assessment is critical because the wrong diagnosis can
cause additional problems and the wrong prescription can have
little or no effect on the problem. Physicians are the ones responsible
for diagnosing ADHD and deciding on the dosage level of Ritalin
to give a child. They should spend quality time getting to know
their client. The sad thing is that this amount of assessment
time is rarely ever done. It has been shown that 50% of all physicians
spend an hour or less diagnosing a child and prescribing medication
for them. In addition to that, most physicians do not properly
monitor the medication they prescribe.
The school psychologist, physician, teacher
and parents should all be involved in the assessment of the disorder.
Interviews should be done in detail with the parents, teacher
and the child. Intelligence and achievement tests should also
be given and evaluated. A thorough medical examination should
be given to establish the medical history of the child and family.
Ritalin should not be given to anyone who has a family history
of tics or Tourette's Syndromes, hearing problems, glaucoma, or
other visual problems. One of the most important parts of the
assessment process is the interview with the child. It is important
for the doctor to know the circumstances and their development
that may have caused the symptoms. The doctor should look for
whether the child is experiencing depression, anxiety, or hallucinations.
The teacher and the parents should also fill out questionnaires
about the child to help in a valid assessment.
Once it has been determined that the child
has ADHD, it is important for the doctor to prescribe the proper
dosage level he believes the child needs. After the drug has been
administered, a close evaluation must be made as to the effect
it is having on the child. There are teacher and parent rating
scales that are used on a weekly basis to measure these effects.
The evaluation is most effective when the child is doing individual
work because that is when the problem is the most noticeable.
Some of the things that the teacher observes are academic performance,
classroom behavior, and organization. The results of these evaluations
are to find out whether the medication is working properly and
whether the child is experiencing any side effects. This is particularly
important because doctors cannot seem to agree on dosage levels.
If a child happens to be diagnosed with a dosage level that is
too high, Ritalin can cause over-focusing and have an adverse
effect in learning ability. If a child tends to get tense, anxious,
agitated, or is under stress, Ritalin could aggravate these conditions.
Teachers have been given a tremendous responsibility
with these children. They have had to become more educated in
the study of ADHD. They are responsible to administer the drugs
to the children before lunch every day. It is the teachers responsibility
for the child to succeed in school. Classrooms have become more
and more unmanageable for the teachers. Kids are under so much
pressure to succeed. Instead of playing and being creative in
school while learning, like the past generations did, creativity,
music, and even recess are slowly being removed from schools.
Kids are now into computers and so much more is expected from
them. The diagnosis of ADHD and the administration of Ritalin
seems to be a "quick-fix" for these problems and helps
the teacher resume control of the classroom. Most of the symptoms
of ADHD reveal normal child-like behavior. We are expecting children
to behave as adults when they haven't had the opportunity to be
children. Child development at a normal pace is important to the
development of a mature adult.
Peter R. Breggin, M.D., Director of the International
Center for the Study of Psychiatry and Psychology, and Associate
Faculty Member at the John Hopkins University, Department of Counseling,
recently wrote a book, titled Talking Back To Ritalin. In it he
says, "ADHD does not reflect children's attention deficits,
but our lack of attention to their needs. The true information
about Ritalin is kept from parents and teachers in order to promote
the sale of the drugs. Drug companies have targeted children as
a big market likely to boost profits, and the children are suffering
as a result. We need to educate - not medicate."
Side Effects Caused By Ritalin
There are many side effects caused by Ritalin,
some of which are frightening. A parent should be aware of these
possibilities and question whether this drug is something they
should really be giving their children. Ritalin can cause a decrease
of the blood flow to the brain; it can cause gross malfunctions
in the development of the brain as well. Research has found that
it can cause atrophy, which is shrinkage of the brain, and other
physical abnormalities that are permanent. Ritalin can cause growth
retardation, a loss of appetite and weight loss; it can cause
increases of the heart rate, blood pressure, body temperature
and respiration; it can cause skin rashes, irritability, nervousness,
anxiousness, insomnia, headaches, stomachaches, nausea and dizziness.
Ritalin has been known to cause emotional problems, depression,
and a proneness to crying. It can cause a child to become robotic,
withdrawn, lethargic, and even suppress creative ability. About
one third of all children taking Ritalin experience what is called
"behavioral rebound," which causes an increase in the
very behaviors the drug is supposed to be treating. This generally
occurs late in the afternoon or evening after the medication begins
to wear off. An additional dose is recommended late in the afternoon
if the behavior is a problem.
Ritalin can cause more serious side effects
such as neurological tics that are permanent, including Tourette's
Syndrome. Other serious side effects are confusion, extreme anxiety,
difficulty breathing, and vomiting. Research has proven that Ritalin
can cause cancer in some laboratory animals; the FDA has not taken
this seriously. Ritalin has been found to cause addiction and
dependency when taken over a long period of time and in excessive
doses. It is recommended that children take a "drug holiday"
on weekends and family vacations. Experiencing these serious side
effects could show that the dosage being taken is too high.
What Ritalin Can And Cannot Do For You
Ritalin does have some benefits, if you want to risk the side
effects. A chemical in the brain, called dopamine, is believed
to be increased with the use of Ritalin. People with ADHD are
thought to have a shortage of this chemical. Ritalin helps to
improve attention, concentration, and performance. Children are
better able to complete homework, follow directions easier, and
their behavior in the classroom improves; they are less aggressive
and more accepted by their peers.
Ritalin is a temporary fix; it does not improve
or heal the problem long term; it does not help you deal with
stress, anxiety, or anger; it does not teach you how to relax,
deal with transition periods, or rebound effects. Once the drug
wears off, the problem returns. In order to get the results, you
must keep taking the drug.
Ritalin Abuse
Until 1980, ADHD wasn't even heard of. In 1996,
the University of Wisconsin performed a survey with three hundred
and ninety six teachers who had students diagnosed with ADHD.
The results showed that 40% were elementary school students, 32%
junior high, and 15 % high school. 66% of them were using Ritalin
to treat the disorder. Recently, psychiatrists have discovered
that ADHD can be carried over from childhood or discovered in
adults. It is estimated that six to nine and a half million adults
have ADHD. In 1992, the number of adults diagnosed with ADHD was
217,000. In 1998, it is expected that 729,000 adults will be diagnosed
with ADHD and receive prescriptions for Ritalin. In the last few
years, the number of children who are now taking Ritalin has multiplied
several times. There have been many questions as to whether or
not this illness is overdiagnosed.
What are we teaching our children by this rising
distribution of Ritalin? We are giving double messages when we
tell them to "just say no to drugs" and then turn around
and give them Ritalin to help them cope with the problems they
are having. Carl L. Kline, a child psychiatrist, believes that
"Ritalin is nothing more than a street drug given to our
children because we don't know what is going on with them."
We are teaching our children to abuse drugs. Children are lining
up at school and the teachers are giving them their daily doses
of amphetamines. Most of these problems could possibly be taken
care of if things were dealt with at home. When we deal with the
emotional problems of children by giving them drugs, we teach
them that in order to cope you need to take drugs.
We are teaching children to become dependent
on drugs to succeed. Christi Rade, a 16 year old student, shared
that Ritalin really made a difference in her grades and without
it she is unable to pay attention. Some people have been known
to stop taking Ritalin after experiencing a false sense of success
and confidence. Tyler Buch, a college student, had a grade point
average (GPA) of 1.8. After taking Ritalin for a year and a half,
his GPA rose to 3.3. He decided to stop taking Ritalin; his GPA
went way down and he dropped out of college.
The signs of abuse are beginning to reveal themselves.
One of the most frightening things about the drug Ritalin is that
it is becoming a recreational drug, much like cocaine. It is scary
to note that Ritalin and cocaine are similar in their psychopharmocology,
meaning that the effect these drugs have on the mind and behavior
are the same. Many say that Ritalin is not addictive and it is
difficult to overdose on Ritalin because it only stays in the
blood stream for four hours. The reality is, too much of anything
over a period of time can be addictive; and too much of anything
at one time can cause major problems, including overdose.
Some overdose signs and symptoms to watch out
for are vomiting, nausea, hallucinations, confusion, severe headache,
high fever, extreme anxiety, delirium, sweating, enlarging of
the eye's pupil, euphoria, redness of the face, hands and other
extremities, uncontrollable muscle twitching, irregular or rapid
heartbeat or breathing, convulsions (sometimes followed by a coma),
and dryness of the mouth and nose.
Ritalin abuse is increasing. If you don't think
we are giving kids the wrong message, here is a startling report.
The DEA and the U.N. International Narcotics Control Board are
concerned about the fact that there have been incidents of teenagers
who are selling their Ritalin to other kids, crushing the pills
into powder, and snorting it like cocaine. On April 24, 1995,
in Virginia, a 19 year old boy, reportedly snorted Ritalin at
a party and then died; a sad, but true story. Another sign of
Ritalin abuse is that doctors recommend giving children the drug
to prevent them from having sleeping problems. This conditions
them to believe they need drugs to help them sleep.
It is a fact that children who have ADHD and
are treated with Ritalin have been known to be kept out of the
armed services. Because of the number of males taking this amphetamine,
this is a frightening possibility if we were ever faced with war.
Possible reasons for this could be that Ritalin has been known
to increase the behavioral problems that it is supposed to decrease.
Ritalin abuse has been known to lead to psychotic episodes, violent
behavior, and severe psychological dependence. As a result, in
March 1996, a campaign to reduce abuse was launched by the manufacturers
of Ritalin. This campaign did a nationwide mailing to doctors
and pharmacists. Unfortunately, it wasn't sent to teachers, parents,
or children. We should be educating our children on the dangers
of taking drugs of all kinds.
Alternatives to Medication
There are alternatives that can be taken besides Ritalin. Some
doctors have chosen to treat ADHD by improving the child's diet.
The best food solution is a well balanced diet in addition to
taking good vitamin and mineral supplements, preferably food form
supplements - not synthetic. Chiropractors believe that a misaligned
spine and skull can cause some of these problems; therefore, chiropractic
care can be a good alternative. Biofeedback, nuerofeedback, integrative
sensory training, and music therapy have also been known to help.
Since many of the child's behavior problems may be cause by their
life at home, individual and family therapy may be very beneficial.
Since ADHD is considered a mental disorder, a good solution might
be to design a school specifically for children with this disorder.
Conclusion
While none of these suggestions have proven to be totally effective,
they sound more reasonable than putting a child on a drug that
can cause serious side effects and conditioning them to become
dependent on drugs for survival. We need to look inward to see
what is causing these problems and deal with the emotional issues.
Parents need to start paying more attention to their children,
spending quality family time with them, and developing healthy
relationships. Teachers should not have to have the pressure of
administering drugs to our children. Our society is producing
"Stepford children" by using drugs to control their
behavior. It is important for parents to look deeply into this
disorder called ADHD, the drug Ritalin, and the possibility of
other treatment alternatives before making a decision. One of
the most important things to know is that there is life beyond
Ritalin.
References
Garber, Ph.D., S. W., Garber, Ph.D., M.D. & Spizman, R. F.
(1996). Beyond Ritalin. New York: Villard.
Runnheim, V.A., Frankenberger, W. R., Hazelkorn,
M. N., (1996). Medicating students with emotional and behavioral
disorders and adhd: a state survey. Behavioral Disorders, 21(4),
306-314.
DuPaul, G. J., Barkley, R. A., McMurray, M.
B., (1991). Therapeutic Effects of Medication on adhd: implications
for school psychologists. School Psychology Review, 20(2), 203-219.
Morrow, D. J. (1997, September 7). Struggling
with lifelong inattentiveness / attention deficit disorder
now being diagnosed in record number of adults. Houston Chronicle,
sect. A, 27.
Livingston, K., (1997, Spring ). Ritalin: miracle
drug or cop-out? Public Interest (127):3-18. Accession Number
01422729. ABI/Inform. UMI Aritcle Clearinghouse Number: 6081.00.
Breggin M.D., P. R., (1996). Whose attention
disorder does ritalin treat? [Letter to the editor].
The New York Times, May 20, 1996, page A14.
Psychiatrist discloses
ritalin's hidden dangers to children. Available http://www.breggin.com/Ritalinprnews.html.
Vital information about ritalin, attention
deficit-hyperactivity disorder and the politics behind the
adhd/ritalin movement. Available http://www.breggin.com/ritalinbkexcerpt.html.
Rimland, B., Academic american encyclopedia.
unknown edition, year and publisher.
Peirce, A., (1996). American pharmaceutical
association. Stonesong Press, Inc.
Price, J., (1996, July). DEA restless about
ritalin: doctors sounding the alarm about a popular drug used
to combat attention disorders in kids. Insight on the news, pp.
39,(1) v12 n25.
Farley, D., (1997, July-August). Attention
disorder: overcoming the conflict. FDA Consumer, p32(4) v31
n5.
Hancock, L., (1996, March). Mother's little
helper. Newsweek, p51 (7) v127 n12.
Back
to articles page
|